Skip to content
Asha / Shared knowledge

religion · Shared topic · Revision 0

Where did Purgatory come from?

Where did Purgatory come from?

Starting explanation, not independently reviewed

The current answer

A practice came first; the place (and the noun) came late.

What remains uncertain

This starting summary presents the original essay’s position. It has not received independent topic review. Its citations have been imported, not checked. Competing explanations and important objections may still be missing.

Show the work

Claims & evidence

Evidence labels are editorial judgments. Arena wins, votes and purchased items do not set them.

unreviewedseed-1

Historian Jacques Le Goff showed the very noun purgatorium surfaces around 1170 (The Birth of Purgatory, 1984); dogma followed at Florence (1439) and Trent (1563).

Imported citation, not independently checked: Jacques Le Goff, The Birth of Purgatory (1984)

unreviewedseed-2

Jews and early Christians prayed for the dead long before anyone imagined a discrete third realm.

Imported citation, not independently checked: 2 Maccabees 12:39-45

unreviewedseed-3

The theological seed (that some sins might be burned away after death) was planted in late antiquity, well before the place was mapped.

Imported citation, not independently checked: Augustine, City of God 21; Gregory, Dialogues IV

unreviewedseed-4

The arc, then, runs from a Jewish prayer for dead soldiers, through Augustine's hesitation and Gregory's ghost-stories, to a twelfth-century noun, to a sixteenth-century dogma.

Imported citation, not independently checked: 2 Maccabees 12; Augustine; Gregory; Le Goff; Council of Trent

The strongest objections

These objections have passed editorial review for relevance. Their inclusion does not settle the disagreement.

No objection has been independently reviewed yet. This is a gap to investigate, not evidence that the answer is settled.

Earn credit by improving knowledge

Choose a useful challenge

Contributions are free. An accepted source, correction, or objection earns a contribution credit shown in your topic profile. Credit cannot buy influence over an answer.

Source scout

Find the original document. Point to the passage that supports or challenges a claim.

Strongest objection

Explain the best relevant counterargument, fairly and precisely.

Clearer answer

Improve the explanation and make its limits easier to understand.

Propose an improvement

Already have an account? Bring your saved account here. Your name, proposal, sources and review decision will be public. Keep private conversations and personal information out of your submission. A different editor must review the change before publication.

Source (optional for a reasoned objection)

Review queue

Proposed changes are not yet part of the answer. Editors must check the sources and explain their decisions.

No proposals are awaiting review.

What changed, and why

Starting draft · Imported from the original essay. Each accepted change keeps its author, sources and independent review.

No editorial decisions have been recorded yet.